I didn’t want to tell her. I thought about lying.
“Yeah,” I said. “They were.”
She put her forehead down on her knees.
“Have you talked to Sophie?” I asked.
“No,” Emma said into her knees. “Her mom took her phone.”
“Why?”
“Because they argued. Sophie and her mom. When Melissa told me I couldn’t swim, Sophie started yelling at her. In the backyard. In front of everybody. And Melissa told her to go inside. And Sophie said no. And then Greg made her go inside. And took her phone.”
“They argued about you?”
Emma nodded. She didn’t lift her head.
“I didn’t want her to get in trouble,” she said. “I told her to stop. She wouldn’t stop.”
I sat down across from her at the kitchen table. In our father’s chair.
“Sophie’s a good friend,” I said.
“I know,” Emma said. “She’s the best.”
She was quiet for a long time.
“Mom would’ve known what to do,” she said finally. Very quietly.
That hurt more than anything Greg had said.
“Yeah,” I said. “She would have.”
I didn’t know what else to say. I didn’t know what to do. I sat there with my sister in our parents’ kitchen and felt, for the first time in a long time, completely useless.
“Call Sophie later,” I said. “When she gets her phone back.”
Around seven o’clock that evening, Sophie’s name lit up on Emma’s phone.
Emma grabbed it off the counter and ran upstairs to her room. She closed the door.
I heard her talking through the door. Low and fast. Then quiet. Then talking again. Then Emma laughed once, a small surprised laugh. Then quiet again.
They talked for almost twenty minutes.
Then Emma came downstairs.
She stood at the bottom of the stairs, holding her phone.
“Sophie wants it moved,” she said.
I looked up from the couch.
“The pool?”
Emma nodded.
“She said if I can’t use it there,” Emma said, “then she doesn’t want her half there either.”
That changed everything.
Because up until that moment, I’d been thinking about it like it was Emma against Greg and Melissa. My sister against their family. Half a pool versus a whole backyard.
But it wasn’t. It was Emma and Sophie. The two girls who bought it. Who earned every dollar. Who counted their envelopes every Sunday night.
Both of them wanted it moved.
“Show me your old messages,” I said. “With Sophie. From when you were saving up.”
Emma sat down next to me on the couch. She opened her phone. She scrolled back. And back. And back.
There were weeks of them. Weeks and weeks of texts between the two girls. About jobs. About prices. About which pool to buy. About how much each of them had saved.
i made $40 today mowing!!!
senator laid down on the sidewalk again i had to carry him 3 blocks
i’m at $156
i’m at $171 cause the sword boys paid extra
omg i found a pool with a better filter it’s only $20 more
And then Emma found the one I was looking for.
It was from the day they set up the pool. Sophie had written it that night.
half yours, half mine forever. dad said we can keep OUR pool here.
With a little blue heart. And a pool emoji.
OUR pool. In capital letters.
I took a screenshot.
Then I asked Emma for Sophie’s number.
“Why?” Emma said. “Are you going to yell at her?”
“No. I’m going to make sure.”
I called Sophie. She picked up on the second ring.
“Hi,” she said. She sounded like she’d been crying.
“Hey, Sophie. It’s Emma’s brother.”
“I know,” she said. “Hi.”
“Emma says you want the pool moved.”
“Yes.”
“You’re sure?”
“Yes.”
“Your parents are not going to like this, Sophie. At all.”
“I know,” she said.
“You could get in a lot of trouble.”
“I’m already in trouble,” Sophie said. “They took my phone for the whole afternoon. I’m only allowed to use it for an hour tonight. And I’m grounded next weekend.”
“Once the pool gets drained,” I said, “it’s a huge pain to move. You can’t just move it back if you change your mind.”
“I know,” she said. “I won’t change my mind.”
I asked her one more time.
“Do you want your half moved too, Sophie? Your half. The money you earned. You want it at our house?”
She didn’t hesitate. Not even for a second.
“Yes,” she said. “It’s our pool. Mine and Emma’s. Not theirs. If Emma can’t swim in it, I don’t want it there.”
So I started making calls.
Our backyard still wasn’t magically level. That was the first problem.
So the first call I made was to Carl.
I walked the two houses down. He was sitting on his front porch in a lawn chair, like he did every evening, with a glass of iced tea and a transistor radio playing a baseball game.
I told him the whole story. He listened without interrupting. When I got to the part about Melissa floating on the pink lounge chair with a glass of wine, his eyebrows went all the way up to his gray crew cut.
“In the kids’ pool?”
“In the kids’ pool.”
“Huh,” Carl said.
He turned off the radio. He stood up. He walked with me back to our house. He walked straight through the side gate into our backyard.
He stood in the back corner for a long time. The corner by the fence, where it sloped down. He stared at it. He walked back and forth. He crouched down and picked up a handful of dirt and let it run through his fingers.
He scratched his chin.
“You can make this work,” he said finally.
“Cheaply?” I asked.
“Define cheaply.”
“Very.”
Carl laughed. A big, rough laugh.
“I’ve got a load of gravel behind my shed,” he said. “Been sitting there since 2019. Leftover from a job. And about forty pavers. Help me clean out my garage next Saturday, and they’re yours.”
“Deal.”
“And the girls help too,” Carl said. He pointed at Emma, who was standing on the back porch watching us. “They’re the ones who want a pool. They can dig for it.”
“Deal,” Emma called from the porch.
We started that same evening.
Carl drove his old pickup truck into our driveway with the gravel in the back. He brought a shovel, a rake, a long wooden board, a level, and a wheelbarrow with a squeaky wheel.
Emma and I spent the rest of the evening hauling buckets of dirt and gravel while Carl stood in the middle of the yard and told us what to do.
“Dig here. Deeper. No, deeper than that. Now fill here. More. No, more.” He laid the long board across the dirt and put the level on top of it. He watched the little bubble. “Still low on the left. Two more buckets.”
We dug out the high side. We filled in the low side. We raked it flat. We poured gravel. We raked it flat again. Carl showed us how to lay the pavers in a big circle for the pool frame to sit on. Emma set every single one herself. She was very careful. She checked each one with the level, the way Carl showed her.
Around eight o’clock, Sophie showed up.
She’d used her one hour of phone time to text Emma. And then she’d walked over. Three streets. In the dark.
“Do your parents know you’re here?” I asked her.
“They think I’m at the library,” Sophie said.
“The library closes at six.”
“They don’t know that.”
She picked up a bucket and started hauling gravel.
I didn’t send her home. I probably should have. But I didn’t.
The three of us, and Carl, worked until almost ten o’clock. Under the back porch light. With the crickets going and Carl’s radio playing the end of the baseball game.
By dark, we had a pad. Rough. Not pretty. But flat and level and ready.
Carl stood back and looked at it with his hands on his hips.
“Well,” he said. “That’ll hold a pool.”
Emma threw her arms around him. Carl patted her on the back awkwardly, twice, like he’d never been hugged before in his life.
“Free admission for life,” Emma said into his shirt. “You get free admission to the pool for life.”
“I don’t swim,” Carl said.
“You can sit next to it.”
He thought about it.
“I can do that,” he said.
The next morning was Sunday.
I spent it on the phone.
It turns out it’s not easy to find somebody who’ll move an above-ground pool on a Sunday on almost no notice. I called seven places. Four didn’t answer. Two said they couldn’t do it for at least two weeks. One laughed at me.
The eighth place was a small company about forty minutes away. The owner answered the phone himself. His name was Luis.
I explained the whole thing. He listened.
“So let me get this straight,” he said. “The kids bought it. With their own money. And the parents are using it and won’t let your sister in?”
“That’s about the size of it.”
He was quiet for a second.
“We’ve got a job in your area this morning,” he said. “We could come by around two. After.”
“Really?”
“Really,” Luis said. “My daughter’s fourteen. If somebody did that to her, I’d move the pool myself. With my bare hands.”
So the “something” I arranged for Greg and Melissa’s pool wasn’t a replacement part. It wasn’t a cover. It wasn’t anything they got to keep.
It was a relocation crew.
At 2:15 that afternoon, a big white truck pulled up on the street in front of Sophie’s house.
It had POOL RELOCATION printed along the side in huge blue letters. Each letter was about two feet tall. You could’ve read it from space.
I’d parked my own truck a few houses down. Emma was sitting next to me in the passenger seat. She was so nervous she was chewing on her thumbnail.
“What if they call the police?” she said.
“Then we’ll show the police the receipt.”
“What if Sophie changed her mind?”
“Then we’ll leave.”
The crew got out of the truck. Four of them. Luis, a tall man with a gray mustache and a clipboard. And three younger guys in matching navy T-shirts. They started unloading hoses. Pumps. Dollies. A big rolled-up tarp.
Melissa saw them first.
She came through her front door so fast it banged against the wall.
She was in shorts and a tank top. She had sunglasses pushed up on her head. She stopped on the front step and stared at the truck.
“What,” she said. “What is that doing here?”
Greg came out right behind her. He looked at the truck. He read the side of it. POOL RELOCATION.
His face went red.
“What the hell is this?” he said. Loud.
For a few seconds, they were both talking at the same time.
“Nobody called you!”
“You’re not coming into our yard!”
“Who authorized this?”
“You can’t just show up here!”
Luis checked his clipboard. He didn’t argue. He didn’t move toward the house. He just stood calmly next to the truck. The same way Carl stood in the backyard, looking at dirt.
“Pool relocation,” Luis said. “We have an order. Twelve-foot above-ground. To be moved to an address on Maple Street.”
“Nobody’s touching my pool,” Greg snapped.
That was when I got out of my truck.
Greg saw me walking up the sidewalk.
He stared.
“You,” he said.
“Morning,” I said. Even though it was the afternoon.
He pointed at the truck. His finger was shaking.
“You can’t just come onto my property,” he said, “and steal something.”
“I’m not asking them to come onto your property without permission,” I said. Very calmly.
I held up a manila folder.
“I’ve got the receipt from the store,” I said. “Four hundred and twelve dollars. I’ve got Emma’s payment records. Two hundred and six. And I’ve got messages showing that the girls bought it together. That it belongs to them. Both of them.”
Greg laughed.
“Emma doesn’t own all of it,” he said.
“I know,” I said.
And the front door opened wider.
Sophie stepped outside.
She was wearing her swimsuit with a T-shirt over it. Her freckled face was very pale. Her hands were shaking. But she walked right out the front door and stood on the front step next to her parents.
Greg turned around.
“Sophie,” he said. “Go inside.”
She didn’t move.
“I told them to move my half too,” she said.
Melissa stared at her daughter.
“What?”
Sophie folded her arms across her chest. Her voice shook a little. But she didn’t stop.
“It’s our pool,” she said. “Mine and Emma’s. We bought it. We paid for it. We set it up. We clean it. It’s ours.”
“We never said you couldn’t use it, Sophie,” Melissa said.
Sophie stared at her mother.
“That’s not the point, Mom.”
“We only wanted to use it sometimes,” Melissa said. “Your dad and me. On the weekends. Is that so terrible? We never get to do anything nice.”
“You didn’t just use it,” Sophie said. Her voice went higher. “You told Emma she wasn’t allowed in. You made her go home. In front of everybody. In front of the Hendersons. She walked home by herself. With her towel. And she didn’t even get it wet.”
Melissa went quiet.
Greg looked at me.
“Where exactly are you putting it, anyway?” he said. “Your yard isn’t even level. You said so yourself.”
I smiled.
“It is now,” I said.
His expression changed.
Luis cleared his throat. He stepped forward with his clipboard.
“Here’s how this works,” he said. Politely. To Greg. “We can drain it, disassemble it, transport it, and reinstall it at the new location. It’ll take several hours. We’ll be very careful with your yard. We’ll pick up everything.”
He paused.
“But we need the property owner’s permission before we go into the yard,” Luis said. “I’m not going into anybody’s backyard without their permission. I won’t do that.”
Greg looked at Sophie. His daughter, standing on the front step with her arms crossed and her chin up.
Then at Emma. Who had gotten out of my truck and was standing on the sidewalk behind me. Holding her yellow envelope. I don’t know why she brought it. It was empty now.
Then at the truck. POOL RELOCATION. In two-foot blue letters.
He let out a long breath.
“Fine,” Greg said. “Fine. Emma can swim here. Whenever Sophie swims. Okay? Whenever she wants. Happy now?”
For a second, I almost said yes.
That was the old me. The me from two years ago. The one who just wanted everything to be smooth. Who didn’t want to make waves. Who wanted everybody to get along so Emma wouldn’t lose her best friend.
Take the deal, that voice said. He’s backing down. Take it. Go home. Don’t make it bigger.
But I thought about Emma walking home by herself with a dry towel on her shoulder.
“That’s not really the issue anymore, Greg,” I said. “Both girls paid for it. Both girls want it moved.”
Then I turned around. I looked at Emma.
For two years, I’d gotten used to making decisions for her.
School. Doctors. Money. Clothes. What we ate for dinner. Whether she went to D.C. Everything. Every single decision in her life went through me. Because there wasn’t anybody else.
But this one wasn’t mine.
She’d earned this one. Twenty dollars at a time.
“It’s still your call, Em,” I said. “If you want to leave your half here, and swim here, like he said, say so now. I’ll send the truck home. Nobody will be mad.”
Emma looked past me. At the backyard fence. At the pool behind it that she couldn’t see.
She was quiet for a long moment.
“I want it moved,” she said.
Melissa looked at Emma.
And for the first time, I saw something on her face that wasn’t smug or annoyed. She looked genuinely hurt.
“Why, honey?” she said. “He just said you could swim here. Whenever you want.”
Emma answered quietly.
“Because I don’t want to wonder,” she said, “every single week, if you’re going to change your mind again.”
Nobody had much to say after that.
Greg stood there for another few seconds. His jaw was working. He looked at his wife. He looked at his daughter.
Then he let out a long breath.
“Fine,” he said. “Move it.”
He turned around and walked back inside.
The crew started draining the pool.
They ran long hoses from the pool out to the street. The water poured into the storm drain. Luis explained to Emma and Sophie exactly how the pump worked. They listened very seriously. He let Emma flip the switch.
It took almost two hours to drain.
Emma and Sophie helped with everything. They took the ladder off. They cleaned out the filter. They helped the crew unhook the metal frame, piece by piece. When the water was finally gone, the two of them got down on their knees and carefully folded the blue liner. Corner to corner. Half, then half again. The way you fold a flag.
Greg came back outside partway through. He stood on his patio, watching. He didn’t say a word. He just stood there and watched his “property” disappear, piece by piece.
Melissa went inside before they were halfway finished. She didn’t come back out.
At one point, I noticed one of Greg and Melissa’s friends from the day before. The woman who’d been sitting on the edge of the pool with her feet in the water. She was standing on the sidewalk across the street, walking a little dog. She stopped and watched for a while.
When I walked past her to get something from my truck, she stopped me.
“For what it’s worth,” she said quietly. “I told them it was wrong. Yesterday. After you left. I told Melissa that was a lousy thing to do to a kid who lost her parents.”
“Thank you,” I said.
“She didn’t listen,” the woman said. “But I told her.”
By evening, the pool was in our backyard.
Luis and his crew set it up on the gravel pad that Carl and Emma and Sophie and I had built. They checked it with a level. Luis crouched down and looked at the pavers for a long time.
“Who did this?” he asked.
“My neighbor,” I said. “And the girls.”
“It’s a good pad,” Luis said. “Real good. Tell your neighbor I said so.”
“Tell him yourself,” I said. “He’s right there.”
Carl was sitting in a lawn chair on our back porch. He’d been there all afternoon. Watching. With his iced tea and his radio. Luis walked over and shook his hand.
“Nice pad,” Luis said.
Carl nodded. “Kids did most of it.”
It barely fit.
The edge of the pool was about eight inches from our back fence. You had to squeeze sideways to walk around it.
The grass around it looked terrible. It was all torn up from the digging and the wheelbarrow and the crew’s boots. The gravel wasn’t pretty. You could see some of the pavers sticking out on one side. And our neighbors on the other side of the fence, the Hendersons, could now see right into our pool from their kitchen window.
The girls didn’t care.
The crew put the hose in and turned on the water. It started filling. Slowly. Emma and Sophie sat on the edge of the frame with their feet dangling down into the pool. There was only about two inches of water in the bottom. Their toes barely touched it.
They were laughing.
About nothing. About everything. About Senator the dachshund. About the sword boys. About Greg’s face when he saw the truck. About the look on Melissa’s face when Sophie came out the front door.
Emma kept looking down at the water. And then looking at me. And then back at the water. Like she still couldn’t believe it was really there.
I paid Luis. He gave me a discount. He wouldn’t say why. He just said, “Tell your sister she’s got a good friend.”
After his truck drove away, I stood on the back porch next to Carl.
“You did good,” Carl said. Without looking at me.
“It was the girls,” I said. “And you.”
“No,” Carl said. “It was you. You could’ve taken that deal. When he offered. I saw your face. You almost took it.”
I didn’t say anything.
“But you didn’t,” Carl said. “You let her decide.” He took a sip of his iced tea. “Your dad would’ve done the same thing.”
I had to look away for a while after that.
The pool took all night to fill.
In the morning, the girls were in it by eight o’clock. The water was freezing. They didn’t care. They screamed every time they went under.
Sophie started spending a lot more time at our house after that.
Most days, she came over after breakfast and stayed until dinner. She’d text her mom where she was. Melissa never texted back. But she never told Sophie to come home either.
Some nights, Sophie ate dinner with us. I made our mother’s spaghetti. With a little bit of sugar in the sauce.
“This is really good,” Sophie said the first time.
Emma looked at me across the table.
“It’s our mom’s recipe,” Emma said.
“Well, your mom was a good cook,” Sophie said.
“Yeah,” Emma said quietly. “She was.”
A week later, Melissa knocked on my door.
It was a Saturday morning. Early. I opened the door in my T-shirt and sweatpants with a cup of coffee in my hand.
She was standing on my front step. No sunglasses this time. She looked tired.
“I handled this badly,” she said.
I didn’t say anything. I waited.
“So did Greg.”
I waited some more. I wasn’t going to make it easy. She wasn’t going to get me to talk yet. Not until she said what she came to say.
She sighed.
“Things have been hard,” she said. “At our house. Greg’s job has been… not great. We had to cancel our vacation this year. We were supposed to go to the lake. We’ve gone to the lake every summer for twelve years.” She looked down at her shoes. “And then the girls put that pool in our backyard. And it was like having a little vacation. Right there. And one Saturday, Greg invited the Hendersons over. And we were having fun. And we just… didn’t want to share it. With kids. For one day.”
She shook her head.
“And then Emma came walking into the backyard. With her towel. And I said the first thing that came into my head. And it was the wrong thing. And then Greg doubled down. Because that’s what Greg does. And then I doubled down. Because that’s what I do.” She laughed a little. Not a happy laugh. “And then there was a pool truck in front of our house.”
“There was a pool truck in front of your house,” I agreed.
She looked up at me.
“Can I apologize to Emma?” she asked.
I called Emma downstairs.
She came down in her pajamas, with her hair a mess. She saw Melissa standing on the front step. She stopped at the bottom of the stairs.
“Emma,” Melissa said. “I’m sorry. What I said to you. About the pool. About our backyard. It was wrong. It was really, really wrong. You earned that pool. You and Sophie. Every dollar. And I had no right to tell you that you couldn’t use it.”
Emma was quiet for a moment.
“Okay,” she said. “Thank you.”
She wasn’t warm about it. She didn’t hug Melissa. She didn’t tell her it was fine. She didn’t say, Don’t worry about it.
But she was polite.
I thought that was fair.
Melissa didn’t ask whether the girls would move the pool back to her house. She didn’t ask whether she and Greg could come over and use it sometime. She didn’t ask for anything.
She just said she was sorry.
Then she nodded at me, turned around, and walked back down my front steps.
“That was nice of her,” Emma said after the door closed. “Right?”
“It was a start,” I said.
“Do you think she meant it?”
I thought about it.
“I think she meant it this morning,” I said. “We’ll see if she means it next week.”
Emma nodded slowly. That made sense to her.
“Sophie said her dad’s been really quiet,” Emma said. “All week. Sophie said he went out to the backyard last night and just stood where the pool used to be. There’s a big dead circle in the grass now. He just stood there looking at it.”
“Maybe he’s thinking.”
“Maybe,” Emma said. She went into the kitchen to get cereal. At the kitchen door, she stopped.
“Hey,” she said. “Thanks. For, you know. Letting me decide.”
“It was your pool, Em.”
“I know,” she said. “But you didn’t have to.”
Last weekend, I grilled burgers in the backyard while Emma and Sophie swam.
It was the first weekend of August. The community pool had finally reopened. The girls didn’t care. They said the community pool was too crowded and smelled like old Band-Aids.
Carl sat in a lawn chair next to the pool with his iced tea and his radio. The girls had officially declared that he had “free admission for life.” They’d even made him a laminated card that said CARL — VIP — NO TIME LIMIT. He kept it in his shirt pocket.
He didn’t swim. He just sat there. Every afternoon. Listening to the baseball game and watching the girls do handstands in three feet of water.
“Carl, watch this!” Emma would yell.
“I’m watching.”
“Did you see?”
“I saw.”
“Was it good?”
“It was an eight.”
“An eight?“
“Your legs came apart at the end.”
Emma was outraged. She did it again. Carl gave it a nine.
I was flipping burgers when Emma splashed me.
A big wave of cold water. Right across the back of my shirt.
“Get in,” she said.
“Absolutely not.”
“Get in!”
“I’m grilling, Em.”
Sophie swam over to the edge of the pool. She held her hand up to me.
“Can you give me a hand?” she said sweetly. “I want to get out. My fingers are all pruny.”
I put down the spatula. I reached out my hand to help her.
She grabbed it with both hands.
And pulled.
Two seconds later, I was in the pool. Fully dressed. Jeans. T-shirt. Sneakers. My phone was in my pocket. Thankfully, it was waterproof.
I came up sputtering.
And Emma was laughing.
She was laughing so hard she couldn’t breathe. She was holding onto the edge of the pool with both hands, bent over, laughing so hard there were tears in her eyes. Sophie was laughing too, that car-alarm laugh. Carl was laughing in his lawn chair. His iced tea was spilling.
But it was Emma I was watching.
I hadn’t heard her laugh like that in two years. Not since before the Tuesday in March. Not since before the young police officer who kept taking off his hat.
That laugh. That real, whole, breathless laugh.
I stood there in the middle of the pool. Soaking wet. In my jeans. With the burgers burning on the grill behind me.
And I just listened to it.
For two years, I thought being Emma’s guardian meant giving her everything I could.
Every dollar. Every extra shift. Every permission slip, every field trip, every pair of glasses. I thought my job was to make sure she never had to go without. To fill the hole our parents left, as much as one clumsy twenty-nine-year-old brother could fill it.
I thought my job was to give.
But standing in that pool, soaking wet, watching my sister laugh, I finally understood something.
Sometimes it isn’t about giving.
Sometimes she earns something herself. Twenty dollars at a time. With grass stuck to her legs and a sword mark on her best friend’s face.
And sometimes she gets to make her own decisions. Even the hard ones. Even the ones I’d make differently.
And my job isn’t to give her everything.
My job is just to make sure nobody takes away what she earned.
“The burgers are burning,” Carl said from his lawn chair.
“I know,” I said.
“You gonna get them?”
I looked at the grill. Smoke was pouring off it.
I looked at Emma. Still laughing. Hanging on the edge of her pool.
“No,” I said.
And I dunked her.
See more on the next page